The Piece of the Month for December 2026
THE SET OF PONTIFICAL INSIGNIA OF FRAY TORIBIO MINGUELLA, O.A.R., CRAFTED IN MANILA IN 1894 BY TOMÁS ZAMORA AND PRESERVED AT THE CONVENT OF THE AUGUSTINIAN RECOLECTS IN MARCILLA
Alejandro Aranda Ruiz
Cultural Heritage
Archdiocese of Pamplona and Tudela
Among the numerous artistic and ethnographic treasures of Philippine origin preserved at the convent of the Augustinian Recollects in Marcilla, this striking set—consisting of a crosier, a pectoral cross, a ring, and a miter—stands out in particular. Crafted in Manila for the Augustinian Recollect friar Toribio Minguella on the occasion of his elevation to the episcopate in 1894, these pontifical insignia constitute a unique testament to late-19th-century Filipino liturgical arts in Navarre.
The Origin of the Set of Insignia: The Episcopal Consecration of Friar Toribio Minguella in 1894
In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, a priest’s elevation to the episcopate was a true social phenomenon. An episcopal election was not only regarded as the most important event in the life of a member of the clergy, but it was also an occasion of singular significance for the particular Church or religious congregation to which the elected priest belonged, as well as for his family, friends, and the town or region from which he hailed. This explains why all these groups took an active part in the consecration, either by playing a prominent role in the ceremony or by helping to defray the costs of the ceremony or the secular festivities surrounding the event. A common “ internship ” in this regard was for the new bishop to be presented with the insignia befitting his new office—insignia that could reach exorbitant prices, as they were often pieces of high-value jewelry and goldsmith work.
Bishop Toribio Minguella’s crozier, made in 1894 by the workshops of Tomás Zamora in Manila. Marcilla, Augustinian Recollects. Photo: José Luis Larrión.
The case of the Augustinian Recollect friar Toribio Minguella y Arnedo (Igea, 1836–Marcilla, 1920), who was elected bishop of San Juan, Puerto Rico, in May 1894, is an excellent example of the significance and enthusiasm— "described as delirious"— with which these events were experienced (El Aralar, August 7, 1894). A good ex test t of this are the festivities held on the occasion of his consecration at the convent in Marcilla on August 5, 1894, during which the Augustinians spent the staggering sum of 10,000 duros, or 50,000 pesetas (El Eco de Navarra, August 7, 1894). The religious ceremony was accompanied by numerous festivities that began the previous day, August 4, with the Apostolic Nuncio’s triumphal train journey from Pamplona to the convent in Marcilla, accompanied by numerous dignitaries, including the Bishop of Pamplona, the Civil Governor of Navarre, and the Viscount of La Alborada. The reporters present on that trip provided a detailed account of the welcomes extended to the nuncio by the residents of the towns along the route. The youth of Caparroso stood out in particular; from the platform of their station, they performed the March of Saint Ignatius on violins, bandurrias, and guitars. Likewise, on the night of August 4, Marcilla celebrated with numerous expressions of joy, such as rockets, bonfires, and fireworks set to the music of brass bands and marching bands. The “ entrance ” leading to the town and the convent was also adorned with four arches made of greenery, decorated with coats of arms, banners, and commemorative inscriptions dedicated by the Marcilla City Council to the nuncio and the consecrating bishops; by the Order of the Augustinian Recollects to the nuncio; by the community of Marcilla to the consecrating bishops; and by their fellow religious to the new bishop of Puerto Rico. On the eve of the festival, these arches, as well as the convent’s façade and its small square, were illuminated with “colored lanterns” and “Venetian-style” paper lanterns (El Aralar, August 7, 1894). The celebrations also included the customary gala banquet on the day of the consecration, at which 160 guests enjoyed “Duchess-style” consommé, lamb and veal ribs “Vidarnese-style, ” salmon and sea bass with vinaigrette and mayonnaise, “aspic-style jellies, ” chicken “à la financier, ” sweet ham with shredded eggs, and vanilla, coffee cream, praline, strawberry, and pineapple ice creams; all washed down with table wine, sherry, manzanilla, and muscatel, as well as Martel, Negrita, Benedictine, and Chartreuse liqueurs (El Aralar, August 7, 1894). The banquet culminated with “classic champagne” and the distribution of “aromatic Havana cigars” (La Unión Católica, August 11, 1894).
In addition to these celebrations, Father Toribio was also honored by various friends with items from the episcopal regalia. The press was careful to mention, among other things, the rings given by Mrs. de Ligués of Cintruénigo, and the Servants of Mary, as well as the pectoral crosses presented by Mrs. Aguado and the new bishop’s godfather (El Eco de Navarra, August 7, 1894), Martín Villar y García, a “ Full Professor ” and former “ President ” at the University of Zaragoza (El Aralar, August 7, 1894).
Bishop Toribio Minguella’s crozier, detail of the volute. Marcilla, Augustinian Recollects. Photo: José Luis Larrión.
A “memento of our brotherly affection”: a gift from the Province of St. Nicholas of Tolentino
But if there was one gift that stood out above all others, it was the one made by the Augustinian Recollect Province of Saint Nicholas of Tolentino, to which the elect Minguella belonged. On June 16, 1894, a few days after learning of Friar Toribio’s appointment as Bishop of Puerto Rico, the provincial, Friar Andrés Ferrero de San José, sent a letter to all the friars in the Philippines urging them to contribute “their share toward the payment of the episcopal insignia which, on behalf of this religious province of San Nicolás de Tolentino, are to be presented to our distinguished son and illustrious brother, the Bishop of Puerto Rico.” As the provincial explained, the gesture intended for Minguella followed the precedent of “what our province has done on similar occasions by offering its distinguished sons a gift to remind them of our fraternal affection and that of this mother corporation” (AM. Box 133, fol. 2). In fact, months earlier, the province had presented a crosier to the newly elected bishop of Casanare (Colombia), Friar Ezequiel Moreno, the future Saint Ezequiel (El Amigo del Pueblo [Manila], February 22, 1894).
Well, the letters, printed in a careful typeface, were accompanied by a brief “ form ” form that the recipient was to fill out with his name, town ( residency program ), and contribution. The provincial’s intention was to use them to create an “artistic and elegant album” to accompany the insignia. Judging by the letters preserved at the Marcilla Historical Archive ( file ), the response from the Augustinian friars was overwhelming, with each contributing according to his means—ranging from the 5 pesos donated by Friar Tiburcio Fernández, a missionary in Ynagauan, to the 10 pesos donated by Friar Juan Labarga, parish priest of Pontevedra (AM. Box 133, fol. 2).
Pectoral of Bishop Toribio Minguella, made in 1894 by the workshops of Tomás Zamora in Manila. Marcilla, Augustinian Recollects. Photo: José Luis Larrión.
Judging by the “ certificate ” issued by the creator of the insignia, the commission was placed with the artist by the attorney general of the Augustinian Recollects, Friar Félix Garcés (AM. Box 126, file 1). Work on their creation must have begun in June or July. On August 8, Provincial Ferrero sent a letter to Father Commissioner Fray Juan Cruz Gómez informing him that they were “working on and nearly ready to deliver the gift,” consisting of “a crosier, a miter, a pectoral cross, a ring […], all of it […] in a beautiful case and accompanied by an album bearing the signatures of all the religious” (Fabo 1927, 35). On August 22, the local newspaper *El Amigo del Pueblo* (Manila) reported that the crosier had been completed, with the rest of the insignia still to be finished. The set must have been completed on the eve of its shipment, since on September 5, Father Andrés Ferrero wrote again to Commissioner Fray Juan Cruz Gómez, announcing that he already had “the gift we are sending to our Father Minguella […] completed and ready for shipment, […] depriving us of the chance to display and admire it on St. Nicholas Day” (AM. Book 45, fol. 33). Indeed, on that very same day, September 5, 1894, the accountant of the Manila customs administration certified that Father Fray Julián Llorente would depart the following day on the steamship León XIII bound for the port of Barcelona, carrying in his luggage “a labeled box containing: a gilded silver episcopal crozier with imitation emeralds, a gold pectoral cross with diamonds, rubies, and imitation emeralds, along with its gold chain also set with emeralds, a gold ring with diamonds and imitation emeralds, and a miter made of taffeta fabric embroidered with silver on a gilded background and adorned with gilded and engraved silver” (AM. Box 126, fol. 1).
The cost of all these badges, placed in an ornate carved wooden box, was considerable. In fact, according to Father Ferrero, the gift was “incomparably better than the one sent to Father Ezequiel” (Fabo 1927, 35). Likewise, *El Amigo del Pueblo* stated that the commission had been placed by asking the artist for “the finest workmanship, without limiting expenses on metals and labor” (August 22, 1894). Thus, in a letter dated December 26, 1894, Friar Gregorio Manrique provided Father Minguella with a breakdown of the “ invoice ” for the episcopal insignia that the province had given him: the cross with chain, 663 pesos; the ring, 195 pesos; the crosier, 642 pesos; the miter, 190 pesos; and the case, 175 pesos (AM. Box 132, file 1). The total came to 1,865 pesos, or 9,325 pesetas, bearing in mind that the Philippine peso was equivalent to 5 pesetas.
Bishop Toribio Minguella's pectoral cross, reverse side. Marcilla, Augustinian Recollects. Photo: José Luis Larrión.
Designers of the insignia: Tomás Zamora’s silversmithing, sculpture, and engraving workshops
The set of insignia was commissioned from the Manila-based artist Tomás Zamora, who ran workshops specializing in silversmithing, sculpture, and engraving on Crespo Street in Manila’s Quiapo district. According to press reports, his workshop produced a wide subject of decorative art pieces related to silversmithing, including religious objects and other items such as ceremonial staffs “and other fine works in accordance with designs and styles” (El Amigo del Pueblo [Manila], January 15, 1894). Furthermore, Zamora referred to himself as “silversmith and engraver of the Royal Palace of Malacañán in this capital, ” which indicates that he was provider of the seat of Spanish colonial power in the Philippines (AM. Box 126, file 1). Furthermore, beginning in 1894, Tomás Zamora held the t position tion of silversmith and sculptor of the Holy Cathedral of Manila (El Comercio [Manila], December 4, 1894).
Tomás Zamora stood out in Philippine society at the time as a renowned and well-known silversmith. On October 22, 1895, *El Comercio de Manila* described a silver altar that the artist had crafted for the church in the Binondo district as “living up to his well-earned reputation.” As a result, he and his team were frequently commissioned by churches, institutions, and private individuals to carry out various projects. For example, he was frequently commissioned to design ( design ) and mint medals, such as the gold medals he created for the Philippine Regional exhibition (El Diario de Manila, February 17, 1895) or the silver medals made for the shooting festival of the Society of San Juan del Monte (El Comercio [Manila], January 30, 1893). Also worth mentioning are ceremonial staffs, such as the one made in 1896 for the justice of the peace of Sexmoan (El Comercio [Manila], July 3, 1893) and the “ framework ” for the “ degree scroll ” (a certificate of adoption) presented to the governor of the province of Bulacan (El Comercio [Manila], May 25, 1895). His works also included religious objects, such as a catafalque (La Oceanía Española, January 3, 1894) and two sets of chalices for Manila Cathedral (El Comercio [Manila], July 15, 1896).
Consequently, it is not surprising that the Recollects turned to him and his workshop to commission Minguella’s pontifical insignia. Not surprisingly, the artist was already known to the religious order, which had commissioned him months earlier to create the crosier for Bishop Fray Ezequiel Moreno (El Amigo del Pueblo [Manila], February 22, 1894). Satisfied with his * work*, the Recollects would commission another work from him: specifically, the silver tabernacle for their church in Manila, which was solemnly inaugurated on the feast of St. Nicholas of Tolentino in 1895 (*El Comercio* [Manila], September 10, 1895).
Pastoral ring of Bishop Toribio Minguella, made in 1894 by the workshops of Tomás Zamora in Manila. Marcilla, Augustinian Recollects. Photo: José Luis Larrión.
The pieces of the set
The set of insignia crafted by Tomás Zamora’s workshop consists of three pieces of jewelry, one textile piece, and one piece of cabinetry. Given the different types of pieces, it stands to reason that various professionals were involved in their creation—in addition to goldsmiths and jewelers—such as embroiderers and cabinetmakers.
Among the pieces of jewelry, the staff stands out above all others. Crafted in gold-plated silver, it consists of a shaft divided into four detachable cylindrical sections topped by a volute. The sections are connected by rings decorated with faux emeralds. The sections, in turn, are decorated with engravings depicting a spiral plant motif. Topping the staff is the volute, adorned with overlapping grape leaves and vines and crowned by a small orb surmounted by a cross made of faux emeralds. The volute rests on a two-part base. The first part, prismatic in shape, features reliefs depicting the busts of the Evangelists on each of its four sides, while the second part, ovoid in shape, bears the coat of arms of the province of San Nicolás de Tolentino flanked by cherub heads. Both the “ design ” of the staff and its craftsmanship drew the most glowing praise from the local press. El Amigo del Pueblo stated that one could “assert without exaggeration that few works of silversmithing can reach this Degree, where the good taste of the design, the filigree chiseling, and the setting of stones are so innovative that they honor the progress of the Philippines in this class of craftsmanship” (August 22, 1894).
The next piece in this episcopal regalia is the gold pectoral cross. It is shaped like a Latin cross with arms ending in trefoils and a circular medallion featuring overlapping fleurs-de-lis, inside which is housed a reliquary (Diario de Manila, September 5, 1894). The obverse is notable for its profusion of gemstones, which, according to the author’ certificate , consist of “imitation diamonds, rubies [and] emeralds” (AM. Box 126, fol. 1). The obverse features chiseled motifs of grapevine leaves, vines, and palm fronds, with the coat of arms of the province of San Nicolás de Tolentino in the center. The cross is accompanied by its corresponding gold chain set with small imitation emeralds.
The ring consists of a gold band with a large faux emerald in the center, surrounded by sixteen brilliant-cut diamonds. According to Philippine newspapers, the sides of the ring are engraved with an allegory of the episcopate on one side and the recipient’s intertwined initials—T M—on the other (El Amigo del Pueblo [Manila], September 5, 1894).
Mitre of Bishop Toribio Minguella, made in 1894 by the workshops of Tomás Zamora in Manila. Marcilla, Augustinian Recollects. Photo: José Luis Larrión.
The gold- and silver-threaded miter completes this set of pontifical insignia. On the front, framed by olive and palm branches—symbolizing peace and triumph—is an embroidered pelican with its chicks, reinforcing the Eucharistic character of the set of insignia, which is also present in the vine leaves on the crosier and the pectoral cross. The same vine leaves and grape clusters are embroidered on the infuillas that hang down the back of the headdress. On this side, the miter features a depiction of the coat of arms of the Augustinian Recollect province to which Minguella belonged. Topping the miter is a small tassel, also known as a “bellota” or “presilla.”
Finally, this entire set was presented to its recipient in a magnificent case carved from various Philippine woods, such as molave, sandalwood, acle, lanete, and camagón. In the center of the lid is, once again, the coat of arms of the province of San Nicolás de Tolentino, surmounted by a cap with twelve tassels, most of which are missing. The coat of arms is flanked by two branches, one bearing vine leaves and clusters of grapes, and the other bearing wheat. The lid is bordered at its edges by a frieze of carved plant motifs and four circular medallions at the corners depicting the theological and cardinal virtues, the Tablets of the Law, and the Mystical Lamb standing over the Book of the Seven Seals. The interior, lined with crimson silk, contains two engraved silver plaques. One of them bears the Recollects’ dedication to Father Toribio: “To the Most Illustrious Son of the Augustinian Recollection, the Most Reverend Father Toribio Minguella, Bishop of St. Joannis Porto-Riquensis, Elect. His Confreres Who Dwell in the Philippine Islands Offer This Present Gift as a Sign of Grateful Remembrance and Affection... MDCCCXCIV” (To the illustrious son of the Augustinian Recollection, the Most Reverend Father Fray Toribio Minguella, elected Bishop of San Juan de Puerto Rico. His fellow friars, who live in the Philippine Islands, offer him this gift as a token of grateful remembrance and affection. 1894). The second, smaller plaque bears the manufacturer’s “ signature ”: “Tomás Zamora Silversmithing, Engraving, and Sculpture Workshops. Manila, 1894.” The casket was particularly praised by his contemporaries, such as the provincial superior, Friar Andrés Ferrero, who, in a letter dated September 5, 1894, to Father Juan Cruz Gómez, referred to it as “a beautiful casket made of the finest woods in the country. Crafted with great care, as these Filipino artisans know how to do” (AM. Book 45, fol. 33).
Mitre of Bishop Toribio Minguella, reverse side. Marcilla, Augustinian Recollects. Photo: José Luis Larrión.
Value and Meaning of the Set of Insignias
As we noted at the beginning, this set of episcopal insignia is, without a doubt, an outstanding example of late-19th-century Philippine liturgical art in Navarre. Added to this is the fact that, to date, there are not many other known Philippine pieces in the Autonomous Community of Navarre that belong to the category of episcopal insignia.
However, regardless of any artistic evaluation , the true significance of this collection of insignia lies in its immense historical value. These insignia speak, first and foremost, to the process of shaping the bishop’s image in the late nineteenth century, which included the prelates’ adoption of a series of insignia befitting their new rank. Particularly illustrative is the aforementioned letter dated December 26, 1894, sent to Minguella by Friar Gregorio Manrique. In it, in addition to mentioning the insignia and their cost, Father Manrique cited the portrait as part of the construction of that image, asking Minguella to send him, along with his first pastoral letter , “the portrait of the bishop, if he has had one painted” (AM. Box 132, fol. 1).
In conclusion, this collection is also an eloquent testament to the extraordinary influence that the Augustinian Recollects acquired in the late 19th century as one of the Church’s great missionary orders, especially in the Philippines. The very symbolism of the objects points to this very fact. In addition to the recurring Eucharistic motifs (vine leaves and bunches of grapes, ears of wheat, and a pelican), the most frequently repeated element in the pieces is the coat of arms of the Province of St. Nicholas of Tolentino, which appears on the crosier, the miter, and the case. Instead of choosing Toribio Minguella’s episcopal coat of arms, his fellow members of the order decided to feature the coat of arms of the religious family. We do not know whether this decision was deliberate or simply due to the fact that, at the time of the commission, they did not know what the new bishop’s coat of arms would be. Be that as it may, it is intriguing to think that it was a conscious choice intended to visually express not only the “fraternal affection and that of this mother corporation” (AM. Box 133, fol. 2), but also to demonstrate in some way that the bond between Minguella and the Augustinian Recollects would not be severed by his rise to the episcopate. Not surprisingly, during the toast at the banquet celebrating his episcopal consecration, Friar Toribio went so far as to say that “if until now I have loved my habit as a religious, I will cherish it even more as a bishop” (Fabo 1927, 41).
Detail of the case for Toribio Minguella’s pontifical insignia, made in 1894 by the workshops of Tomás Zamora in Manila. Marcilla, Augustinian Recollects. Photo: Alejandro Aranda.
Sources and bibliography:
file Agustinos Marcilla (AM). Box 126, file 1.
AM. Box 132, file 1.
AM. Box 133, file 2.
AM. Book 45, folios 28–33.
El Amigo del Pueblo (Manila).
El Aralar
El Comercio (Manila).
El Diario de Manila.
El Eco de Navarra.
La Oceanía Española.
La Unión Católica.
Fabo, P., Life of His Excellency Father Toribio Minguella, Bishop of Sigüenza, Barcelona, publishing house bookshop Religiosa, 1927.