aula_abierta_pieza_del_mes_2026_noviembre

The Piece of the Month for November 2026

"THE ANNUNCIATION WITH PROPHETS" BY FEDERICO ZUCCARO: AN ITALIAN " model " IN THE PARISH OF OTEIZA DE LA SOLANA

Pilar Andueza Unanua
University of La Rioja

The Parish of San Miguel

Although historical records trace the origins of the parish of San Miguel de Oteiza de la Solana to the Middle Ages average, the church we see today is the result of several subsequent construction phases. In the 16th century, the chancel and the “ Wayside Cross ” were built, and starting in 1704, the nave and the tower were constructed. Later, between 1773 and 1779, additional work was carried out to add a two-part portico, featuring two sets of triple arches, and a sacristy attached to the chancel on the Epistle side.

The sacristy

According to Aramendia Garzia, the sacristy was built in 1774 by Sebastián de Ondicola, a stonemason from Makaia, in the Navarran region of leave . To do so, he followed the plans drawn up by Pedro José Lezaún, a master mason from Estella, who—along with fellow mason Fermín Zurbano, from Oteiza de la Solana—took charge the following year of covering that slightly irregular quadrangular space with a dome of orange- average , resting on pendentives. The dome was divided into eight sections by means of recessed radial bands resting on a stepped cornice and cut-out panels. 

According to * agreement * (Accounts of the Church of San Juan), based on the * data * (Accounts of the Church) provided by the author himself, in 1789 the painter and gilder Juan Francisco Santesteban, a resident of Pamplona, was paid for the painting, marbling, and decoration of the sacristy. It may therefore be assumed that this artist was also the creator of the pictorial decoration found both on the pendentives—where he depicted the Tetramorph—and on the dome itself, whose surface he completely covered with an unusual motif originating in Italy: the Annunciation with Prophets (Fig. 1). 

 
Fig. 1. Juan Francisco Santesteban, *The Annunciation with Prophets*, 1789. Sacristy of the San Miguel Parish Church, Oteiza de la Solana (Photo: Pilar Andueza)

The origin of this scenic iconography can be traced to the fresco painted by Federico Zuccaro (1542–1609) in the Church of Santa Maria dell’Annunziata in Rome. This church, affiliated with the Roman “ high school ” of the Society of Jesus, was consecrated in 1567, and it was on the barrel vault of its apse that Zuccaro painted a large fresco depicting the Annunciation between 1566 and 1567. In 1626, the church was demolished to make way for a large church dedicated to Saint Ignatius following his recent canonization. Only a small portion of the original building and a fragment of the aforementioned fresco, depicting the Virgin Mary (Fig. 2), have survived. 

 
Fig. 2. Federico Zuccaro, Detail from *The Annunciation with Prophets*, fresco. Church of St. Ignatius, Rome (Photograph: Simone, “L’idea del disegno…,” p. 120)

This prominent Italian artist, who trained alongside his brother Taddeo, worked in various places such as Florence, Rome, and Venice, as well as in the Netherlands and England; he was also commissioned by Philip II to work on the Basilica of San Lorenzo de El Escorial. His style can be classified as late Mannerism, influenced by Michelangelo and Raphael. His compositions, generally large in scale, are characterized by spatial complexity, the presence of numerous stylized and elongated figures, gestural expression and movement, as well as a strong narrative sense and a prominent emphasis on drawing. 

Aware of the importance of the painting created at the Annunziata and proud of it, the artist commissioned the renowned engraver Cornelis Cort to reproduce the scene as a print. The three versions created by the Dutch artist were published in Rome in 1571 by Antoine Lafréry and dedicated to Antoine Perrenot, Cardinal Granvela, as revealed by the inscriptions at the bottom (Fig. 3). The Louvre Museum holds a drawing of the Annunciation by Zuccaro himself, and although it could be a preparatory drawing for the fresco at the Annunziata, it seems more likely that it was conceived to assist Cort with the “ work ” (Fig. 4). 

 
Fig. 3. Cornelis Cort, The Annunciation with Prophets, 1571, engraving, 46 x 68 cm. British Museum, London, inv. no. 1917,1208.675.1-2
Photo: British Museum

 
Fig. 4. Federico Zuccaro, The Annunciation, brown pen and ink, brown wash, black chalk, and sanguine on paper, 44.8 x 66.3 cm. Louvre Museum, Paris, inv. no. INV 4539
Photograph: Musée du Louvre

In turn, Cort’s work was copied shortly thereafter by other prominent engravers such as Girolamo Olgiati (Fig. 5), Raphael Sadeler (Fig. 6), and Gaspar ab Avibus (Gaspar Osello). But the significance of the Roman Annunciation led to it also being copied by various painters, as demonstrated, for example, by the painting preserved at the Lope de Vega House Museum (Fig. 7) and another found at an antiques market (Fig. 8). 

 
Fig. 5. Girolamo Olgiati, The Annunciation with Prophets, 1572, engraving, 46.6 x 67.9 cm. British Museum, London, inv. no. V,8.190.
Photo: British Museum

 
Fig. 6. Rafael Sadeler, The Annunciation with Prophets, 1580, engraving, 30.9 x 45.4 cm. British Museum, London, inv. no. 2002,0127.36
Photograph: British Museum

 
Fig. 7. Anonymous, The Annunciation with Prophets (copy by Federico Zuccaro), oil on canvas, 91 x 121 cm. Lope de Vega House Museum. (Photo: David Serrano on CER.es)

With this work, Zuccaro revolutionized the depiction of the Annunciation, a scene that traditionally offered few variations, all of which had a distinctly intimate character. The Italian painter introduced significant innovations in what became his first major solo work, created without the collaboration of his brother and teacher Taddeo, who had already passed away. To achieve this, he created a scene of great theatricality and grandeur inspired by the spatial achievements of the Renaissance, arranging a large composition divided into two levels—an earthly space and a heavenly one—which he accompanied with a brilliant treatment of light and shadow, thereby conveying a sense of the infinity of space. Thus, in the center of the lower section, strongly illuminated by the light emanating from the halo, he placed the main figures: the Virgin Mary and Saint Gabriel. She appeared on the left, in a contemplative and serene pose, facing a prie-dieu with a book and a spindle for spinning—symbols of humility and diligence. Opposite her, the archangel, kneeling and more expressive in his gestures, offered her a bouquet of lilies, a symbol of purity. 

Flanking the main figures were two groups of three prophets each, identifiable by their respective attributes and the tablets with text they were holding. On the left, he placed Moses (“The Lord your God will raise up for you a prophet from among your own people and from your brothers, just as I am”), Isaiah (“Behold, a virgin shall conceive and beara son”), and King David (“I will set one of your own descendants on your throne”), while on the right he placed Solomon (“Let my beloved come into his garden”), Jeremiah (“The Lord has created something new on the earth: A woman will encircle a man”), and Haggai (“A little while longer, and the One desired by all nations will come”). All these prophets shared a common thread: they had foretold the coming of Christ in the Old Testament. 

He completed the lower level at the ends of the composition with two landscape backgrounds, one featuring the sun on the left and the other the moon on the right—“pulchra ut luna, electa ut sol” (Song of Songs 6:10)—accompanied by various Old Testament Marian symbols drawn from the Song of Songs, Sirach, and the Book of Wisdom. Thus, beneath the sun were depicted the city, the rose, the lilies, the temple, the palm tree, the garden Closed, the flower, and the olive tree; beneath the moon, the cedar, the mirror, the well, the plane tree, the cypress, the “ source ,” and the tower (Fig. 8). 

Continuing with the scene, in the upper portion—representing the heavenly realm—the Eternal Father appeared, blessing from amid the glory, and below him, the dove of the Holy Spirit descending toward the earth. Both were surrounded by angelic choirs arranged among the clouds. He completed the scene in the upper corners with Adam and Eve. 

In this way, the ensemble presented a complex iconographic program centered on the beginning of redemption through the Incarnation of Christ, set in contrast to original sin, represented by Adam and Eve. In this context, the prophets played a fundamental role as heralds of the coming of the Messiah. 

 
Fig. 8. Anonymous, The Annunciation with Prophets (copy by Federico Zuccaro), late 16th century. Antiques market (Photo: Marmolejo, “Federico Zuccari and the Society of Jesus…,” p. 42).

This work by Zuccaro had a major impact in Spain, particularly on the Andalusian Baroque school, in both painting and sculpture, as evidenced by artists such as Zurbarán, Murillo, Mohedano, Ocampo, and Pacheco, who, in his treatise *The Art of Painting*, recommended this iconography for depicting the Gospel scene of the Annunciation.

Since the original mural lasted just over fifty years, the artists who copied or drew inspiration from this scene decades later—after the church that housed it had disappeared—must have become familiar with it through the aforementioned engraved prints. We must not lose sight of the extraordinary impact that the printing press had on visual culture in the Modern Age, as it made it possible to reproduce the same image countless times, making it available to artists and artisans in places far removed from its place of origin. 

Prints became not only a means of training in workshops, but also a source source of inspiration and a repertoire of iconographic and formal models. Their small size, their medium—paper—their portability, and their relatively low price facilitated their circulation. They thus became a fundamental tool for the transmission of models and the professional development of artisans and artists, who incorporated the iconography of the prints into their own compositions with varying Degrees of fidelity. Hence, they sought to collect prints—prints they acquired at fairs, markets, on trips, and so on. 

It is within this context that Juan Francisco Santesteban’s work should be viewed. The painter must have had in his possession one of the prints depicting Zuccaro’s Annunciation, either because he had access to it directly or—as seems more likely—because it was provided to him by the person who determined the iconographic program to be executed on the dome of the parish church in Oteiza, most likely a “ member of the clergy.” 

Juan Francisco Santesteban simply transferred all the main figures from the print to the wall with great fidelity, except for God the Father and the Holy Spirit. The main challenge lay in adapting the scene to the dome-shaped space of the sacristy and adding color to it. To achieve this, he distributed the six prophets across six of the eight panels, concentrating some of the Marian symbols in the spaces designated for David and Jeremiah, and reserving the remaining two panels for the Virgin Mary and Saint Gabriel (Figs. 9–11). He placed each of the figures on the outermost part of the dome, though he managed to give unity to the whole by situating the glory—with clouds and angelic choirs—at the upper apex of the panels, extending it continuously throughout the central part of the composition.

 
Fig. 9. Depiction of the Virgin Mary and Saint Gabriel in the print by Cornelis Cort and in the sacristy at Oteiza

 
Fig. 10. Depiction of King Solomon in the sacristy of Oteiza and in the print by Cornelis Cort

 
Fig. 11. Depiction of King David in the sacristy of Oteiza and in the print by Cornelis Cort

" result " was a sensationalist composition that demonstrates the continued existence, in the late 18th century, of an iconographic " model " created in Rome more than two centuries earlier. Although its execution displays a more naive style and a much more modest technical quality than Zuccaro’s monumental composition, Oteiza de la Solana’s painting constitutes an interesting example of the circulation and adaptation of images through prints. 

Sources and bibliography

ARAMENDIA GARZIA, Miguel, Oteiza: Notes on Ethnology and Ethnography for a Brief Local History, 2007.
BRITISH MUSEUM, “The Annunciation with Prophets,” Collection Online, Museum number 1917,1208.675.1-2. London. 
GARCÍA LUQUE, Manuel, “Engraved Sources and European Models in Andalusian Sculpture (1600–1650),” in GILA MEDINA, Lázaro (ed.),The Consolidation of the Baroque in Andalusian and Latin American Sculpture, Granada, University of Granada, 2013, pp. 179–256.
GONZÁLEZ MARTEL, Juan Manuel, “The Annunciation,” catalog entry for the Lope de Vega House Museum. CERES. network Digital Catalog of Spanish Museum Collections, Ministry of Culture.
MORALEJO, Macarena, “Federico Zuccari and the Society of Jesus,” Ucoarte. Journal of Art Theory and History, 1, 2012, pp. 33–52.DOI
MUSÉE DU LOUVRE, The Annunciation, Federico Zuccari, INV 4539, Front, Department of Graphic Arts, Louvre Collections. Paris.
PACHECO, Francisco, *The Art of Painting: Its Antiquity and Greatness*, Seville, Simón Faxardo, 1649, p. 498.
SIMONE BOLZONI, framework, “The Idea of Drawing: Forms of Thought and Graphic Practices in Federico Zuccari,” L’Idea. Disegni, II, 2, 2025, pp. 97–127.DOI